The
Polish government is wrong to ban discussion of the nation’s role in
the Nazi slaughter of the Jews. It needs to face the demons of the past
History
is complicated enough without getting the police involved. But in
Poland debates about the darkest event of the 20th century could soon
spill over from the seminar room and editorial pages and into the
courts, even the prison cells. That’s because a new law,
awaiting the president’s signature, would impose a fine or up to three
years in jail for anyone found guilty of blaming “the Polish nation” for
the Holocaust.
It’s an obvious, nationalistic move by the hard-right Law and Justice party, which rules Poland.
But it raises tricky questions, not only about that country but about
how to best to safeguard the truth, a question that has become
increasingly vexed – even urgent.
Advocates for the law say their chief target is the phrase “Polish death camps”,
which they insist is a slander because Auschwitz-Birkenau, Treblinka,
Sobibór and the rest were established and operated by Nazi Germans,
albeit on Polish soil. It was German SS officers, not Poles, who were in
charge. Nor were there Poles among the guards and camp personnel, who
were often Ukrainian. What’s more, around 2 million non-Jewish Poles
were themselves murdered by the Nazis.
That’s all correct: we should speak of Nazi, not Polish, death camps.
But the new law goes much wider than this. It seeks to outlaw any
suggestion that “the Polish nation”, undefined, was “responsible or
co-responsible for Nazi crimes committed by the Third Reich”. And here
is where things get tricky.
For this seeks to cast Poles as blameless in the slaughter that took
place in their midst, to hand them a “certificate of virginity”, in the
words of Konstanty Gebert, a journalist for Gazeta Wyborcza whose most recent column
dared prosecutors to come after him. “I hereby state,” he wrote, “that
numerous members of the Polish nation are co-responsible for certain
Nazi crimes committed by the Third Reich.”
What he has in mind is, for example, Jedwabne,
where in 1941, one half of the town murdered the other half, the
non-Jewish Poles turning on their Jewish neighbours – people they’d
known for ever, people they had sat next to in school
– eventually herding hundreds of them into a barn and burning it to the
ground. All told, they murdered 1,600 people.
Jedwabne is a singular case, but of the 3.2 million Jews who were
murdered in Poland a sizeable number died at the hands not of Nazi
Germans but of their fellow Poles. In Hunt for the Jews,
the Polish-born historian Jan Grabowski estimates some 200,000 Jews met
their end that way. His meticulous mining of the archive revealed a damning picture.
Grabowski found case after case of Jews who had escaped the ghettoes
and fled into the forests, only to be handed over to the Nazis by the
Polish villagers who found them. Some Poles were coerced into taking
part in this hunt for the Jews, but others were eager volunteers. The
historian found documents that told how Bronisław Przędział, from the
village of Bagienica, found two Jews while searching the woods near his
home. After he betrayed them, Przędział demanded his reward from the
German occupiers: 2kg of sugar. The rate varied. In some places it was
500 złoty for every Jew. Elsewhere it was two coats, formerly worn by
Jews, for each Jew brought in.
Of course there were brave, righteous Poles who risked their lives to harbour Jews. Israel’s Yad Vashem Holocaust
museum has recognised 6,706 Poles for such acts of heroism – more than
any other country. But the uncomfortable truth is that the rescuers were
the exception, a “tiny, terrorised group who feared, most of all, their
own neighbours”, according to Grabowski.
And let’s not forget the Polish Blue Police, who stood guard outside
many of the ghettoes and who, according to contemporaneous testimony,
were responsible for many, many more Jewish deaths. Under German
command, maybe they were in an impossible position; maybe they didn’t
yet comprehend the full murderous intent of the Nazi occupiers. The
point is, these are precisely the kind of difficult, morally fraught
judgments that require honest exploration and open debate. That cannot
happen under threat of prosecution. The new law grants an exemption to
historians. But who will define who is a historian? Even if Grabowski is
immune, what about a journalist who reviews his book?
It’s not hard to see why this has happened. Polish nationalists want
Poles to have been the untainted victims of Nazism: it’s hard to admit
that too many were willing assistants to genocide. Like almost every
nation occupied by the Nazis, and unlike Germany
itself, Poland has not yet made a clear-eyed reckoning with its past.
It has not fully wrestled with the fact that a Jewish community that
once made up 10% of its population, and which was the largest in Europe,
has gone, murdered en masse in just over three years. “Poland is not at
peace with its Jewish ghosts,” says Gebert. “These are phantom limbs.
You amputate the limb and it still hurts.”
Predictably, Israel has sought to hit back with a draft law of its
own, making it a crime punishable by jail to deny or diminish the role
played by those who connived with the Nazis in persecuting Jews. I
understand this impulse, especially when Holocaust denial, or otherwise
tormenting Jews with the most painful event in their history, is now
such a core component of anti-Jewish racism. Witness this week’s report
that antisemitic incidents in the UK rose by over a third, to a record high, with these the words most commonly deployed in anti-Jewish posts on social media: Jews, Holocaust, Hitler, Nazis, Holohoax, gas.
But it is not the right remedy. I am against both the new Polish and
Israeli laws for the same reason I oppose any measure criminalising
Holocaust denial. Not because I don’t find such denial vile: I do. But
because the truth is a plant that cannot be protected by keeping it
behind walls, in the shadow of the law. It can thrive only out in the
open, where it will be buffeted by argument, to be sure – but where it
can also breathe and grow and live.
• Jonathan Freedland is a NewsGossipBull.com columnist
Popular
-
submitted by /u/ManiaforBeatles [link] [comments] by /u/ManiaforBeatles via World News
-
submitted by /u/ahm713 [link] [comments] by /u/ahm713 via World News
-
submitted by /u/DoremusJessup [link] [comments] by /u/DoremusJessup via World News
-
China Successfully tests ICBM defense system for first time China Airbase, China (Reuters) - The Chinese military...
-
FOX NEWS FIRST: Anti-Trump FBI lovebird defies subpoena; Trump slams 'inappropriate' Russia deal at NATO summit Fox News We...
-
Truck Driver in Crash That Devastated a Hockey Team Is Sentenced to 8 Years The New York Times OTTAWA — A truck driver whose inattention...
-
submitted by /u/DingDongInDaPingPong [link] [comments] by /u/DingDongInDaPingPong via All news, US and international.
-
A native bee in my backyard (Credit: Ferris Jabr) I have been fascinated with living things since childhood. Growing up in n...
-
Officials Look to Quadruple Number of Asylum Seekers Sent Back Over Border The Daily Beast Border officials are aiming to quadruple the ...
-
Veteran climber says "it's been an especially bad year" on Mount Everest CBS This Morning Expert climber says overcrowdin...